Would you pick the same two professions again after a few weeks in?

Stormwind, early evening, and I'm sitting at the auction house mailbox with my bags completely stuffed because I picked two gathering professions on my first character and never thought past the moment of actually having bags full of raw materials with nothing to do with them. It felt sensible at the time, wander around, pick things up, watch the little numbers tick, except now I'm staring at a pile of stuff and realizing I have no crafting profession to turn any of it into something useful, so I just mail it all to an alt and hope that counts as a plan.

The guides I've read mention that the crafting side got new recipes across all six professions this time around, plus that new Camping system turning the Basic Campfire into something that actually makes things and gives buffs, which sounds lovely in theory but I haven't touched it yet because I'm still busy picking flowers.

So here's what I'm curious about, from people who've actually had a few weeks to live with their choice rather than just picking blind on day one like I did: if you could go back to character creation knowing what you know now, would you choose the same pair of professions again, or has something about how they play out in practice made you wish you'd gone a different way?

The double-gathering trap is real, you're not alone there. Mailing raw materials to an alt is a reasonable stopgap, but it's a sign you're missing the other half of the loop rather than an actual plan.

A few things worth sorting out before you answer your own question:

• Does your alt actually have a crafting profession that uses what you're gathering, or are you just moving the clutter problem one character over?
• With new recipes added across all six crafting professions this time, there might be more demand on the auction house for raw materials than usual, so pure gathering could still pay off even without a crafting pair.
• Have you tried the Camping system yet? If Basic Campfire now works as a crafting station with buffs attached, that might be worth factoring in before you decide gathering-only was a mistake.

I wouldn't call your choice wrong, just incomplete for where you are now. Whether you'd pick the same pair again really depends on whether you want to sell raw goods on the auction house long-term or eventually craft for yourself and your guild. What's your guild situation like, are people asking you for materials or finished items?